Ask Dr. Potato

With 806 posts, chances are there's already an answer to your question. Please try searching below before submitting a question to Dr. Potato. Use multiple words to help narrow down the results. For example, search for "potatoes" and "group" if looking for an answer on cooking potatoes for large groups.

Back To Dr. Potato Home

Q & A: Baked Potato Soup

Q: Who invented baked potato soup?
You might just be able to trace this back to the Irish, or to the French, when lines of people gathered for food handouts and mixtures of cheap ingredients became a soup.  Modern variations of the baked potato soup emerged at the chains Steak & Ale and Bennigan’s and can easily be traced back to the question “what are we going to do with these left over baked potatoes?”  Well, some became potato skins, with the insides scooped out to become mashed potatoes. Some leftover bakers were re-purposed into twice baked potatoes, but some also became soup.  Speaking of delicious and hearty soups…does anyone out there remember the steak chain Victoria’s Station headquartered in the San Francisco bay area?  They had a wonderful steak soup comprised of left over chunks of prime rib.  Note: Victoria Station grew to 100 locations before closing in 1986.Moving on to baked potato soup.  What makes a great one?  Usually those that incorporate some of the toppings you find on a loaded baked potato such as shredded cheddar cheese, sliced green or spring onions, real bacon bits or chunks, and a dollop of fresh sour cream.
  • Here is a recipe from the Idaho Potato Commission website that you might be interested in: Jean's Baked Potato Soup.
  • This isn’t a baked potato soup, but oh my gosh it is good and so rich: Potato Soup with Brie.
  • And here is a potato soup recipe with chunks of Idaho Potatoes and Glacier Vodka: Potato Vodka Soup.
If you want to do a taste test of chain restaurant baked potato soup recipes before developing your own, start with the family dining chain Shari’s:  This is a signature recipe, and in Idaho Falls is only $1.99 with the order of any entrée.