Ask Dr. Potato

With 921 posts, chances are there's already an answer to your question. Please try searching below before submitting a question to Dr. Potato. Use multiple words to help narrow down the results. For example, search for "potatoes" and "group" if looking for an answer on cooking potatoes for large groups.

Back To Dr. Potato Home

Idaho® Potatoes and Potato Soup


I’d like to peel and cut my Idaho® potatoes the night before.  I plan to cover them in cold water and store them in the refrigerator.  However, I have a question about that.  I’m making potato soup so I assume I want the starch in the water.  If I add 1 ½ Tbl of salt, or vinegar or lemon to the water, I’ll have to pour it off.  Will it work to not add anything to the water and use the soaking water for the soup?  If not and I pour off the water, will I be losing too much starch for my soup to thicken as much as the recipe would have otherwise?  Lastly, could I soak them in chicken broth vs. water and use the broth in the soup?  Mostly I’m concerned about losing the starch if I pour off liquid, be it water or broth.


These are all good questions.  When making fresh fries I have found when cutting the potatoes and storing them in water overnight there is usually a little starch that is at the bottom of the container and can be kept for later use as a thickening agent for soups or starches by just pouring off the water slowly.

The lemon juice or white wine vinegar won’t add much to the overall flavor, so I usually just use the water as needed without any negative results. Adding salt to the water will flavor the potatoes, so you probably should drain that off before making the soup. The cut potatoes should have enough starch, in any case, to work well as a thickener. Yes, you can soak the potatoes in chicken broth, again, I would refrigerate the broth just like the water when added to the cut potatoes.

Here is a little secret you may want to try for thickening soups… keep some dry instant potatoes on hand and add a little to the soup mixture to thicken. I like this method because you can add as much as you want. Give it a try.