How long do you suggest baking a potato in a small toaster oven?

Just about every recipe will include the caveat: Oven temperatures and cooking times will vary, even in a standard size radiant or convection oven. As for a toaster oven, there is a wide range of oven strength and capacity, and in this case, will also depend on the size of the potato. Unfortunately, the recipe caveat applies here as well, and the answer is subject to some trial and error.